|
By Dr. Juan
Hernandez
When it comes to
immigration, it seems the chaos on the border is
exceeded only by the chaos in Washington.
That is especially
curious since Members of Congress are usually famous
for being able to read which way the political wind
is blowing. In this case, however, it appears they
would be well served to commit to reading the
results of a recent, reputable bi-partisan national
survey of voter attitudes on immigration.
What its findings
show is not at all startling, and is indeed
testimony to the common sense of US Americans.
With solutions to
border, immigration, and guest worker issues so
logical and obvious, it can only be the handiwork of
feuding Washington special interest groups to have
befuddled and complicated what is clear and simple.
Most noteworthy for
Congress among the findings is that two-thirds of
all voters say they would be more likely to vote for
a candidate who favors the type of immigration
approach identified in the survey!
Here are highlights
from the findings of a bi-partisan poll on
immigration taken in March by Republican pollster
Lance Tarrance, and Democratic pollster Celinda
Lake, commissioned by the National Immigration
Forum.
The survey shows
that fully 75% of likely voters favor a proposal
with the following components:
P
Registration
of undocumented workers as temporary guest workers,
P
Temporary work visas
for seasonal and temporary workers,
P
Provides newly
registered workers with a multi-ear process for
legal
residency and
eventual citizenship,
P
Provides newly
registered workers with no preferential treatment
for
citizenship,
P
Provides penalties
for workers or employees who violate these laws
P
Puts a priority on
reuniting close family members.
Seems logical and
fair enough! Which is undoubtedly why it enjoys the
support of 78% of Republicans, 77% of Independents,
and 70% of Democrats, and 70% of Hispanics and 78%
of whites, alike. Moreover, 69% of likely voters
said they would be more likely to support a
Congressional candidate who favored a comprehensive
approach to reform, rather than the ad-hoc,
piecemeal approaches currently working their way
through Congress. Enforcement-only strategies miss
the point, and the majority of people recognize them
for what they are: emotional reactions that do not
recognize nor solve the problem. Everyone
recognizes that the system is broken and needs to be
fixed. But let’s not make the cure worse than the
disease.
Most Americans,
including myself, have legitimate concerns about the
need to keep our borders secure from terrorists.
This is no trivial concern in a post-September 11th
world in which our intelligence services continue to
uncover evidence of terrorist intentions.
Our message to
Congress should be this: “Let’s prioritize this
issue! Let’s bring together the political leadership
of both nations, immigration leaders, Hispanic
leaders, and other interested parties to start
hammering out the framework of a reform proposal
that is comprehensive, bipartisan, fair and worthy
of the people of two great nations. Why not create a
U.S.-Mexico Congressional Summit in Washington, D.C.
that brings some sanity out of the chaos?”
I believe it is time
now for Congress to put the issue of immigration on
a front burner before the next election cycle causes
the issue to become mired in election-year politics.
Fair, pragmatic,
bipartisan, comprehensive-yet-fairly-simple
solutions are possible. The time is now for
Congress to wake-up and lead on immigration reform.
Survey results clearly show the American people
stand prepared to politically reward those do so.
|